The tornadoes that swept through Missouri last year will cost homeowners who didn’t feel so much as a stiff breeze. Home insurance rates in Missouri are rising a little more than 5 percent, according to figures from the Missouri Department of Insurance.
Illinois state insurance officials wouldn’t provide an estimate on how much homeowners premiums may be rising this year.
People in the insurance industry call 2011 “the year of the cat,” as in catastrophe. And that partly explains the rising cost of home insurance here.
Several tornadoes ripped through St. Louis: one on New Year’s Eve of 2010 and then on April 22. Tornadoes laid waste to parts of the mid-South in April, then a massive twister erased much of Joplin in May. All told, twisters killed 1,900 people last year.
The result was the fourth biggest disaster loss in the history of insurance. The $21.3 billion tornado loss ranked just short of the $24 billion cost of 9-11, $25 billion for Hurricane Andrew in 1992 and $47.6 billion for Katrina in 2005.
The tornadoes capped a decade of disaster, in which catastrophic losses of all sorts more than doubled from the 1990s. This year is also shaping up as nasty with 270 tornadoes reported as of March 5, compared to a 7-year average of 123, according to the insurance rating firm A.M Best.
Tornado losses used to be a minor headache for insurers, who were more worried about hurricanes on the coast.
“Insurers are starting to say, ‘maybe this is the new normal,’” said Steve Weisbart, chief economist for the Insurance Information Institute, an insurance trade group. “They’re building into rates a little more margin for catastrophic loss.”
They’re also trying to bolster sagging profits. Earnings for property and casualty insurers dropped about 40 percent last year to $11.7 billion as “catastrophe-related losses wreaked havoc,” according to A.M. Best.
And so, St. Louis homeowners will be paying higher prices for coverage. The Missouri Department of Insurance says that insurers covering 80 percent of homes have filed rate increases averaging a bit over 5 percent from July of last year to early this month.
That was actually lower than in previous years. “Base rates” – rates before any discounts - rose 14 percent in 2009 and 9 percent in 2010, according to Missouri Insurance Director John Huff.
Those 2009 and 2010 increases were due in part to another ‘catastrophe’ hitting insurers — poor returns on their investments.
Investment income has taken a big hit in recent years because of low interest rates, and falling investment income was pushing up rates before the rash of tornadoes.
Insurance premiums also depends on other factors, such as the amount of competition in the market and the amount of loss claims.
Huff says competition remains strong in Missouri with 130 companies angling to cover homes.
Insurers are looking for ways to lower their disaster losses beyond simply raising rates. More are moving to percentage deductibles, under which the homeowner pays a fixed percentage of any loss, says Weisbart. That’s a step away from fixed deductibles, in which the homeowner pays a certain dollar amount with the insurance company paying everything else up to the policy limit.
In Missouri, regulators are seeing some insurers move away from coverage that replaces damaged property with new property. If an old roof is blown off, they may give the owner a check for the value of an old roof, even if it costs more to replace it with a new roof.
Homeowners have to read their policy to know that they’re getting. “It’s really up to the consumer to do their own homework,” says department spokesman David Owen.
Source